Background & Issues:
- Warren, a CPC letter carrier, was charged in 2021 for allegedly leaving the scene of an accident and suspended for five days by CPC (later reduced to 2.5 days).
- He applied for short-term disability, which was denied after six weeks.
- In June 2023, charges were stayed or dismissed; he sued D’Alfonso and Lifework for defamation, discrimination, and racism.
- Sought to increase lost wages claim to $110,000 and add new defendants.
Court’s Rulings:
-
Amendments Allowed:
- Lifework renamed Telus Health in the claim.
- CPC added as a defendant due to a potential defamation claim based on Sicard’s July 6, 2021, letter accusing Warren of dishonesty and lack of integrity, which was shared with third parties.
-
Proposed Defendants Denied:
- D’Alfonso removed (Warren conceded).
- Rodricks’ letter (Feb 6, 2024) was routine, not defamatory.
- Sicard & Keating acted within employment scope; CPC is vicariously liable.
-
Defamation Claim Against CPC:
- Charge dismissal in 2023 revived limitation period; claim not time-barred.
- CPC’s internal handling of allegations, including distribution of the letter, is relevant.
Next Steps:
- Warren has 30 days to amend his claim.
- CPC and Telus Health have 30 days to respond.
- Mandatory mediation within 120 days.
No damages or costs were awarded at this stage.
