Edge v Moose Jaw Downtown and Soccer/Field-House Facilities Inc.
Graham Edge
Law Firm / Organization
Butz & Company
Lawyer(s)

M. Danish Shah

Moose Jaw Downtown and Soccer/Field House Facilities Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
McKercher LLP
Ted Schaeffer
Law Firm / Organization
McKercher LLP
Brian Swanson
Law Firm / Organization
McKercher LLP
Scott McMann
Law Firm / Organization
McKercher LLP
Crystal Froese
Law Firm / Organization
McKercher LLP

Background Facts:

  • Graham Edge was hired as the general manager of Moose Jaw Downtown and Soccer/Field-House Facilities Inc. (DFHF) on January 15, 2018. DFHF was a non-profit corporation established by the City of Moose Jaw to manage public facilities.
  • Edge was dismissed for cause on May 24, 2018, during his probation period, with the board citing "incompatibility with staff and relationships with third-party groups."
  • Edge alleged he was actually fired for initiating an investigation into harassment allegations against another employee.
  • On April 15, 2020, Edge filed a wrongful dismissal lawsuit against DFHF and its directors (Ted Schaeffer, Brian Swanson, Scott McMann, and Crystal Froese).

Key Legal Issues:

  • Whether Edge’s claim was barred by the one-year limitation period in The Cities Act.
  • Whether DFHF’s directors could be personally liable under The Non-profit Corporations Act.
  • Whether the respondents intentionally concealed documents, affecting the limitation period.

Court’s Decision:

  • The claim against DFHF was dismissed as statute-barred under The Cities Act.
  • The claim against the directors was reinstated, as the Chambers judge erred in applying the limitation period to them.
  • The matter regarding document production was remitted for further consideration.

Award & Costs:

  • The appeal was allowed in part.
  • No costs were awarded due to divided success.
Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan
CACV4270
Labour & Employment Law