Bowmanville Lakebreeze West Village Ltd. v. Thangavel
Bownmaville Lakebreeze West Village Ltd.
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

Ankush Sondhi

Rokulan Thangavel
Law Firm / Organization
Perrys LLP
Anojan Thangavel
Law Firm / Organization
Perrys LLP

Background:

  • The defendants, Rokulan and Anojan Thangavel, purchased a home from the plaintiff, financed partly by a $500,000 vendor take-back mortgage (VTB).
  • After moving in, they discovered construction defects. The plaintiff undertook repairs, and the defendants moved out.
  • The defendants defaulted on the VTB. The plaintiff sued for possession and $572,691.16 plus 18% interest.
  • The plaintiff obtained a substitute service order after failed attempts at personal service. The defendants did not respond, leading to a default judgment on October 28, 2021.
  • The plaintiff initiated power of sale proceedings, resulting in the property's sale.

Court’s Decision:

  1. Release of Sale Proceeds:

    • $249,833.83 released to the defendants, with $28,000 deducted for costs owed to the plaintiff.
  2. Vacating the Writ of Execution:

    • The plaintiff consented to lifting the writ.
  3. Setting Aside Default Judgment:

    • Denied under the Mountain View Farms test:
      • Motion not brought promptly (two-year delay).
      • No plausible explanation for failure to respond.
      • Defendants had an arguable defense regarding VTB charges but no viable construction defect claim due to limitation periods.
      • Greater prejudice to the plaintiff if judgment was set aside.
      • Granting relief would undermine justice due to defendants’ avoidance of service.
  4. Consolidation with a Related Application & Summary Judgment Motion:

    • Both denied.

Costs:

  • No costs awarded due to the plaintiff’s failure to file motion materials.

Final Outcome:

  • Default judgment stands; defendants may still challenge VTB charges through a related application?.
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-21-309
Real estate
$ 249,834
Plaintiff