John Doe v Edgewood Holdings (2013) Ltd.
John Doe
Law Firm / Organization
Kazlaw Personal Injury Lawyers
Edgewood Holdings (2013) Ltd.
Law Firm / Organization
Guild Yule LLP
Dr. Gary Richardson
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

P. Pilley

Dr. Mel Vincent
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

P. Pilley

The Estate of J.B.
Law Firm / Organization
Unrepresented

Background:
John Doe, the plaintiff, was admitted to Edgewood Holdings (2013) Ltd.'s private addiction rehabilitation facility from October 11, 2016, to December 7, 2016. His spouse arranged the admission without a prior medical diagnosis. The plaintiff alleged that Dr. Gary Richardson and Dr. Mel Vincent misdiagnosed him with a severe substance use disorder and that he was coerced into treatment. During his stay, he claimed to have been sexually assaulted by his roommate, J.B.

Legal Issues:

  • Medical Negligence & Informed Consent – Doe argued that the physician defendants failed to properly assess his condition, provide alternatives, or obtain his informed consent for treatment.

  • False Imprisonment – He alleged he was unable to leave due to psychological coercion.

  • Vicarious Liability – He sought to hold Edgewood responsible for the physicians' alleged negligence.

  • Breach of Fiduciary Duty – He claimed the defendants failed to act in his best interest.

Court's Decision:
The court denied the plaintiff’s application to amend his claim due to unclear pleadings but allowed him to reapply with a revised version. It noted inconsistencies between the false imprisonment and informed consent claims.

Costs:
The court awarded costs to Dr. Gary Richardson, Dr. Mel Vincent, and Edgewood Holdings (2013) Ltd., but did not specify an amount.

Supreme Court of British Columbia
S219922
Civil litigation
Defendant