Respondent
Petitioner
Background Facts:
Raymond Lorne Hellmen and Shannon Lee Wallis owned Lot 1 in Kamloops, British Columbia, which benefited from a registered easement over Lot 2, owned by Stephen Leonard Hartwick and Jil Meredith Forbes. The respondents obstructed the easement with parked vehicles, a fence, and a gate. Structures from the petitioners’ property, including a dripline, eaves, and a retaining wall, also encroached onto Lot 2.
Legal Issues:
The case addressed two key issues:
Court Findings:
The court ruled that the easement allowed passage only and prohibited parking or storage. The respondents’ fence and gate substantially interfered with access to Lot 1 and were ordered removed, though a motorized gate with shared access was permitted. For the encroachments, the court granted an Encroachment Easement, ordering the petitioners to pay $4,000 in compensation to the respondents.
Outcome:
The petitioners were awarded partial relief but were required to bear their own legal costs unless further submissions were made within 60 days.
Key Judgment:
The case reinforced easement rights while balancing property use, ordering reasonable remedies for both parties.
Court
Supreme Court of British ColumbiaCase Number
S62152Practice Area
Real estateAmount
Winner
PetitionerTrial Start Date
Download documents