Case Overview:
Garry Alexander Iron (plaintiff) sued Bateman’s Jewelry (defendant) for $4 million, claiming wrongful conviction for robbery caused by false testimony from the defendant’s employees. His conviction was overturned in 2022 due to flawed witness identification procedures.

Key Legal Arguments:
Iron alleged the defendant’s employees’ testimony led to his wrongful imprisonment, causing physical and mental harm, defamation, and financial loss. The defendant sought to strike the claim under Rule 7-9(2)(b) of The King’s Bench Rules, arguing it was frivolous and barred by the doctrine of witness immunity, which shields witnesses from civil liability for court testimony.

Court’s Decision:
The court dismissed the defendant’s motion, finding the claim was not frivolous despite its deficiencies. It ruled that witness immunity, while a strong defense, did not automatically render the claim meritless. The court acknowledged the plaintiff’s self-represented status and allowed the case to proceed.

Costs and Award:
No costs were awarded, and the dismissal was without prejudice, permitting the defendant to bring further pre-trial motions.

Conclusion:
The court allowed Iron’s case to continue, affirming his right to seek damages for his alleged wrongful conviction and harm, despite procedural defenses raised by the defendant.