Arnbrecht v Isaac
Paul Arnbrecht
Law Firm / Organization
Oliver & Co.
Lawyer(s)

Jeremy Koch

Katherine Ellen Isaac
Law Firm / Organization
HSJ Lawyers LLP

Case Overview:
The case arose from a motor vehicle accident (MVA) on December 26, 2018. Mr. Arnbrecht sought damages for injuries sustained in the collision. The defendant, Ms. Isaac, admitted liability.

Injuries and Impact:
Mr. Arnbrecht suffered a serious right shoulder injury, chronic pain, and other physical limitations that affected his ability to work and perform household or recreational activities. Despite shoulder surgery, his pain persisted, limiting his physical endurance and work capacity.

Key Legal Issues:

  1. Non-Pecuniary Damages: Mr. Arnbrecht claimed $150,000, citing chronic pain and lifestyle impairments.
  2. Loss of Earning Capacity: He argued for $73,000 in past losses and $334,000 to $493,500 for future earning capacity, asserting that his injuries reduced his ability to maintain consistent employment.
  3. Cost of Future Care: He sought $282,000, including for medical treatments, property maintenance, and health equipment.
  4. Loss of Housekeeping Capacity: He requested $180,993, citing diminished ability to perform household and farming tasks.

Court’s Decision:
The court awarded:

  • Non-pecuniary damages: $100,000
  • Past earning capacity loss: $7,990
  • Future earning capacity loss: $120,000
  • Cost of future care: $62,522

The total award amounted to $290,512. Claims for loss of housekeeping capacity were dismissed. The court found the defendant fully liable, awarding costs to Mr. Arnbrecht.

Supreme Court of British Columbia
S1917354
Personal injury law
$ 290,512
Plaintiff