Embedia Technologies v Blumell
Embedia Technologies Corporation
Embedia Sales Corp.
James Reid Blumell
Law Firm / Organization
Miller Thomson LLP
Blumell Consulting Ltd.
Law Firm / Organization
Miller Thomson LLP
Tyson McDonald
Law Firm / Organization
Miller Thomson LLP
Draper Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Miller Thomson LLP

Key Legal Points:

  1. Applicable Legal Standards:

    • The application was brought under both Rule 4.22 of the Alberta Rules of Court and section 254 of the Alberta Business Corporations Act (ABCA).
    • Rule 4.22 sets a lower standard for proving inability to pay compared to section 254.
  2. Financial Evidence:

    • Draper relied on expert analysis of Embedia’s financial records, concluding Embedia lacked cash or assets to cover costs and could not borrow sufficient funds.
    • Embedia countered with pending purchase orders but offered no definitive proof of financial improvement.
  3. Decision Basis:

    • The court found on a balance of probabilities that Embedia could not pay costs if the defense succeeded.
    • The court deemed it unjust to let Embedia proceed without sufficient financial security.
  4. Quantum of Security:

    • The court awarded $126,000 for the first litigation stage, broken into:
      • $100,000 (taxable fees)
      • $10,000 (expert fees for questioning)
      • $10,000 (transcript costs)
      • $6,000 (GST).
    • Payment split into two $63,000 tranches, with conditions for stays if payments are missed.
Court of King's Bench of Alberta
1701 14578
Corporate & commercial law
$ 126,000
Defendant