Plaintiff
Defendant
Overview:
Floyd and Susan Heidecker (plaintiffs) claimed negligence and breach of contract against Carmen Campbell (defendant) and her associated brokerage, 100% Realty Associates Ltd. The case revolved around Ms. Campbell’s failure to act on a time-sensitive condition in a real estate transaction.
Facts:
The plaintiffs sought to purchase a property in Osler, Saskatchewan, contingent on selling their Ottawa home. Ms. Campbell failed to notify them about a 48-hour clause triggered by another offer. As a result, the plaintiffs’ contract to purchase the Osler property was terminated.
Legal Issues:
Negligence: Ms. Campbell admitted liability for her failure to act on the notice.
Breach of Contract: The plaintiffs argued that Ms. Campbell violated her duty of care under the agency agreement.
Liability of Brokerage: The court dismissed claims against 100% Realty Associates, finding Ms. Campbell was an independent contractor.
Damages: Plaintiffs sought costs related to the failed transaction, including increased property costs, travel, storage, and mental distress.
Judgment and Costs:
The court awarded the plaintiffs $9,401.29 for special damages, covering travel, storage, mail costs, and partial reimbursement for household items. Claims for increased property costs and mental distress were denied. The action against 100% Realty Associates Ltd. was dismissed.
Significance:
The judgment underscored the limits of liability for independent contractors and clarified the application of betterment and mitigation principles in negligence claims.
Court
Court of King's Bench for SaskatchewanCase Number
QBG-SA-00920-2018Practice Area
Real estateAmount
$ 9,401Winner
PlaintiffTrial Start Date
Download documents