Leanne Homes Limited v. Singh
Leanne Homes Limited
Law Firm / Organization
Sutherland Law
Lawyer(s)

Paras Anand

Avtansh Singh
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

Stuart Reddington

Gurmeet Singh
Law Firm / Organization
Unrepresented
Parneet Kaur Dhunna
Law Firm / Organization
Unrepresented

Key Facts:

  • Issue: Leanne Homes Limited (LHL) alleged a breach of an Agreement of Purchase and Sale (APS) by the defendants for a home in Shelburne, Ontario, priced at $1,182,990. The defendants had paid a $170,000 deposit but failed to close on January 18, 2024.
  • Relief Sought: LHL requested an interlocutory injunction to prevent Avtansh from selling his Mississauga property or alternatively, an order to hold sale proceeds in trust.

Court's Analysis:

  1. Test for Injunction: Following RJR-MacDonald Inc. v. Canada, the test included:

    • Serious issue to be tried.
    • Irreparable harm to the plaintiff.
    • Balance of convenience.
  2. Serious Issue to Be Tried: The court acknowledged the prima facie breach of contract claim as sufficient.

  3. Irreparable Harm:

    • The court found no evidence that LHL would suffer harm beyond the $170,000 deposit already held.
    • LHL failed to quantify its damages or prove urgency.
  4. Balance of Convenience:

    • The harm to Avtansh, who resides in the property, outweighed LHL’s concerns.

Decision:

  • The motion for an injunction was dismissed as LHL did not satisfy the irreparable harm test.
  • Costs: Expected to be awarded to Avtansh, likely around $3,500.

Additional Notes:

  • Gurmeet Singh and Parneet Kaur Dhunna absconded and were not represented.
  • LHL retains the $170,000 deposit, which could mitigate potential damages.
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-24-00000475-0000
Real estate
$ 3,500
Defendant