Kirpichova v. Galaxy Real Estate Core Ontario LP
Marta Kirpichova
Law Firm / Organization
Self Represented
Emad Elguindy
Law Firm / Organization
Self Represented
Galaxy Real Estate Core Ontario LP
Law Firm / Organization
Gardiner Roberts LLP
Lawyer(s)

Rob L. Winterstein

  1. Relief Sought by Tenants, Marta Kirpichova and Emad Elguindy:

    • A stay of an eviction order issued by the Landlord and Tenant Board in 2022 for unpaid rent.
    • Relief pending leave to appeal a Divisional Court decision upholding the eviction and directing payment of funds held in trust to the landlord, Galaxy Real Estate Core Ontario LP.
  2. Background:

    • Tenants stopped paying rent in November 2020, accumulating arrears of ~$54,000.
    • Multiple proceedings at the Board, Divisional Court, and Court of Appeal have upheld the eviction and ruled against the tenants’ appeals.
  3. Court’s Analysis:

    • Test for Stay: Applied the standard test for an interlocutory injunction:
      1. Serious Issue to Be Tried: No merit found; tenants seek to relitigate settled issues.
      2. Irreparable Harm: Tenants failed to demonstrate genuine harm (e.g., evidence suggested they could make alternate living arrangements).
      3. Balance of Convenience: Favored landlord due to ongoing financial losses caused by non-payment and delays.
    • Court cited a history of unsuccessful litigation by tenants aimed at delaying eviction.
  4. Outcome:

    • The motion for a stay was dismissed.
    • Costs of $4,952.79 awarded to the landlord.
Court of Appeal for Ontario
M55519; COA-24-OM-0327
Civil litigation
$ 4,953
Appellant