Plaintiff
Defendant
Background and Context:
William Kuntang Ma, the plaintiff, initiated numerous legal proceedings against Guo Qiang Dai, Chang Ying Xu, and Hui Han, related to disputes over property and familial relationships. Central to the litigation was a property at 4053 West 38th Avenue, Vancouver. The disputes stemmed from Ma's claim that Han, his ex-spouse, held the property in trust for him, and accusations that Dai and Xu conspired against him.
Key Legal Issues:
Court’s Findings and Orders:
Justice Whately declared Ma a vexatious litigant, barring him from initiating further proceedings without leave. The court struck his pleadings for being inflammatory, prolix, and abusive of court processes. Ma’s cross-application was dismissed.
Costs Awarded:
The defendants were awarded standard costs at Scale B. Special costs were declined as the judge did not find Ma’s conduct in this specific application sufficiently reprehensible.
Key Outcome:
The court underscored the need for judicial economy and warned Ma against future abuse of legal processes.
Court
Supreme Court of British ColumbiaCase Number
S232870Practice Area
Civil litigationAmount
Winner
DefendantTrial Start Date
Download documents