Background:
On January 9, 2019, Andrew Matwijec’s Mazda 3 was t-boned by Bradley Edward Goodridge’s Toyota Yaris in Surrey, British Columbia. Goodridge admitted liability for the accident. Matwijec, a 49-year-old laborer, sustained soft tissue injuries, bilateral rotator cuff tears, chronic pain, and psychological injuries. These injuries rendered him unable to work in his physically demanding job and severely impacted his quality of life, including his ability to perform household tasks and engage in social activities. Before the accident, Matwijec was physically active, socially engaged, and optimistic about his career.

Legal Arguments and Issues:
The dispute centered on damages. Matwijec argued that his injuries and diminished earning capacity stemmed entirely from the accident, including exacerbation of pre-existing conditions that were previously asymptomatic. The defense claimed that his injuries were partially attributable to pre-existing conditions and a failure to mitigate damages by declining surgeries, treatments, and lighter-duty employment.

Damages Awarded:
The court awarded Matwijec $1,011,653.25, including $235,000 for non-pecuniary damages, $215,000 for past income loss, $500,000 for future income loss, $13,200 for past housekeeping capacity, $39,242 for future housekeeping, $2,243.25 for future care, and $2,968 in agreed special damages.

Key Findings
The court determined that the accident caused Matwijec’s injuries and rejected reductions based on pre-existing conditions or mitigation failures. It ruled he was permanently unable to work even in sedentary roles due to severe physical and psychological impairments.