Price et al v. State Farm et al
Lori-Anne Christine Elizabeth Price aka Lori-Anne Christina Elizabeth Price aka Christina Price
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

J. Brown

Christos Price by his litigation guardian Lori-Anne Christine Elizabeth Price aka Lori-Anne Christina Elizabeth Price aka Christina Price
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

J. Brown

State Farm Insurance Company
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Matteo Costanza by his litigation guardian Bozana Skojo
Law Firm / Organization
Mackesy Smye Lawyers
Lawyer(s)

Devan T. Schafer

Sheila Evans
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Nadine Lejambe
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Estate of Dean Joseph Costanza aka Dino Costanza
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified

Key Issues and Decisions:

  1. Suspensory Order: Plaintiffs sought to suspend the administration of Dean Costanza’s estate under Section 59 of the Succession Law Reform Act.

    • Ruling: Denied. The insurance payout was already distributed; thus, no estate assets were available for suspension.
  2. Mareva Injunction: Plaintiffs requested to restrain Bozana Skojo from dissipating the insurance proceeds designated for Matteo Costanza.

    • Ruling: Denied. Insufficient evidence was provided to prove a risk of asset dissipation.
  3. Inclusion of Life Insurance in Estate: Plaintiffs argued the insurance payout should be part of the estate under Section 72(1)(f) to fund dependant support claims.

    • Ruling: Denied. The court held that the funds, already paid to a designated beneficiary, were protected under Section 72(7).
  4. Trust Deposit Order: Plaintiffs sought an order to hold the insurance proceeds in trust.

    • Ruling: Denied. This was seen as a collateral attack on a prior order directing the payout to Skojo.

Background:

The dispute centers on a $500,000 life insurance policy for Dean Costanza’s son, Matteo. Christina Price claimed dependant support for her son, Christos, arguing a common-law relationship with Costanza. Previous rulings validated the insurance payout to Matteo’s guardian, Ms. Skojo.

Next Steps: Costs submissions are due by December 24, 2024, if unresolved. No monetary award was specified.

Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-18-64445
Insurance law
Defendant