Blench v Cheng
David Travis Blench
Law Firm / Organization
Hu Young Law
Lawyer(s)

Hu Eliot Young

Minling Cheng also known as Yinning Cheng
Law Firm / Organization
Verhaeghe Law Office
Lawyer(s)

Monica Wang

Background:

  • The defendant, Minling (Yinning) Cheng, was found in contempt on February 7, 2024, for failing to disclose her assets as ordered.
  • The defendant attempted to stay the enforcement of this contempt finding, but her application for a stay was dismissed by the Court of Appeal on February 26, 2024.

Key Points:

  1. Contempt Finding: Cheng failed to comply with an order from October 2022 to disclose assets, leading to contempt.
  2. Stay Application: Cheng appealed and sought a stay of the contempt order, which was dismissed. The costs of this application were remitted to Justice Dunlop for determination.
  3. Costs Submissions:
    • Plaintiff sought $5,139.30 in enhanced costs.
    • Defendant argued that she should not pay any costs and instead be awarded $5,000.
    • Defendant also raised misconduct allegations against the plaintiff's lawyer, which were not considered due to procedural issues.
  4. Ruling on Costs:
    • The plaintiff, as the successful party, was awarded $4,218.75 in costs, with disbursements and GST added, totaling $5,497.64.
    • An additional $1,000 was awarded for costs related to the cost determination process itself.
Court of King's Bench of Alberta
2203 12124
Civil litigation
$ 5,498
Plaintiff