Soltis v Citadel Mews Ltd
Brian Soltis, As Executor of the Estate of Mary Soltis
Law Firm / Organization
Lawson Lundell LLP
Citadel Mews Ltd.
Law Firm / Organization
Bryan & Company LLP
Lawyer(s)

Kevin Chapotelle

Devonshire Security Corp.
Law Firm / Organization
Bryan & Company LLP
Lawyer(s)

Kevin Chapotelle

Gregory Christenson
Law Firm / Organization
Bryan & Company LLP
Lawyer(s)

Kevin Chapotelle

Key Facts:

  • Mary and Edward Soltis entered a "life lease" for a unit at Citadel Village East, a retirement complex, with an upfront payment of $403,500 (the “Entrance Fee”) treated as a loan to Devonshire.
  • Upon the lease termination (due to Mary’s death in 2022), repayment of this amount was delayed as more than 6% of residents had also given termination notices.
  • Mary’s estate was placed first in the payout queue.

Plaintiff's Claims:

  • Seeks a partial summary judgment for $372,495 (remaining amount of the Entrance Fee).
  • Requests assignment of the mortgage securing the Entrance Fee repayment to the plaintiff.

Court's Decision:

  1. Partial Summary Judgment Granted:
    • Judge ruled that Devonshire must pay the remaining amount ($372,495) plus interest, as the requirements for repayment were met when the unit was re-leased in November 2022.
    • The court denied holding Citadel jointly liable for this payment.
  2. Mortgage Transfer Request Denied:
    • The Loan Agreement only allowed the plaintiff to request a mortgage transfer, which Devonshire was not obligated to grant.

Outcome: Partial judgment in favor of the plaintiff; costs and specific amounts subject to further hearing if disputed

Court of King's Bench of Alberta
2303 10236
Real estate
$ 372,495
Plaintiff