28 Aug 2024
Surefire Dividend Capture, LP v. National Liability & Fire Insurance Company (Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance)
Background:
- SDC invested $31.2 million USD in BRC, a hedge fund.
- The investment was lost due to a Ponzi scheme by Brenda Smith, BRC’s CEO, who was later convicted of securities fraud.
- SDC sought indemnification from Berkshire under a fidelity bond for fraud-related losses.
Legal Issues:
- Intervention: The Ancillary Receiver for BRC sought to intervene in the appeal to affirm BRC's status as an insured under the Bond, affecting its own claim against Berkshire.
- Appeal: SDC appealed the trial court's interpretation, which found BRC, not SDC, was the insured entity eligible for claims.
Court Decision:
- Intervention Granted: The court allowed the Ancillary Receiver to intervene, provided authorization from the U.S. Court is obtained.
- Conditions: The Ancillary Receiver must file a factum by August 30, 2024, without introducing new evidence.
- Proceedings: The intervention will not delay the appeal scheduled for September 9, 2024.
Key Points:
- The appeal challenges the interpretation of insurance coverage under the Bond.
- The court found the intervention necessary for presenting BRC’s perspective.
- The appeal will determine whether SDC or BRC can claim under the Bond.
Successful Party:
- The Ancillary Receiver, granted leave to intervene, is the successful party for this motion.
Monetary Award / Costs / Damages:
- No specific monetary awards, costs, or damages were mentioned. The focus is on procedural matters.