Plaintiff
Defendant
Background:
Stephen B. Pineau, former CEO of Viscount Systems Inc., was accused by his former employer of making $67,000 in unauthorized charges. In January 2015, Business in Vancouver published an article by Tyler Orton, implying Pineau's involvement in dishonest activities. Pineau sued Glacier Media Inc., Business in Vancouver, and Orton for defamation.
Legal Issues:
The court focused on the damages owed to Pineau for the defamatory article, assessing whether it implied corruption and whether the defendants’ conduct justified aggravated or punitive damages.
Damages Awarded:
The court awarded Pineau $120,000 in general damages, recognizing the significant harm to his reputation. The court found that the article suggested dishonest conduct, leading to serious personal and professional consequences for Pineau. However, the court did not find the defendants' actions to be malicious or reckless enough to warrant aggravated or punitive damages, noting their failure to verify Pineau’s response to the allegations as careless but not malicious.
Apology and Mitigation:
The defendants issued a public apology in June 2022, which the court considered in mitigating the damages.
The final judgment awarded Stephen B. Pineau $120,000, with no additional damages for aggravation or punishment.
Court
Supreme Court of British ColumbiaCase Number
S170597Practice Area
Tort lawAmount
$ 120,000Winner
PlaintiffTrial Start Date
Download documents