Grisdale v 816-838 11th Avenue SW
Dan Grisdale
Law Firm / Organization
Miles Davison LLP
Matt Lowe
Law Firm / Organization
Miles Davison LLP
David Bell
Law Firm / Organization
Miles Davison LLP
816-838 11th Avenue SW (GM Glenbow Inc)
Law Firm / Organization
Bishop & McKenzie LLP

Background:

  • The Applicants, creditors of a failed brewery, Inner City Brewing Company Inc. (ICB), purchased the secured debt owed by ICB to Bank of Montreal (BMO).
  • They sought to enforce their security under s.62 of the Personal Property Security Act (PPSA) by taking and selling ICB’s equipment.
  • Before the equipment was removed, the Respondent, ICB’s landlord, seized it for unpaid rent (distraint).

Key Legal Issues:

  1. Validity of the Applicants' Claim under s.62 of the PPSA:
    • The Applicants failed to involve a civil enforcement agency as required by the PPSA, rendering their attempt to seize and sell the equipment invalid.
  2. Landlord’s Right to Distraint:
    • The court held that the Respondent was entitled to seize the equipment to recover rental arrears as the Applicants' actions were invalid under the PPSA.

Decision:

  • The Applicants' application to set aside the Respondent’s distraint was dismissed. The Respondent may proceed with distraint in accordance with the PPSA.
  • There is no specific amount for costs awarded in the decision.

Conclusion: The Applicants' attempt to enforce their security interest without using a civil enforcement agency was invalid under Alberta law. The landlord’s distraint for rental arrears took precedence.

Court of King's Bench of Alberta
2301 14510
Civil litigation
Respondent