2024 ONSC 4636

• Claims and Counterclaims:

  • The plaintiff, Joe Alessandro of Law Help Ltd., sued Joseph Gavin Briggs for defamation and economic interference.
  • Briggs counterclaimed for fraudulent misrepresentation, breach of duty of loyalty and good faith, and unjust enrichment, stemming from Alessandro’s unlicensed legal practices.

• Rulings:

  • Alessandro and Law Help Ltd. committed intentional misrepresentation by holding themselves out as licensed legal professionals, causing Briggs financial and personal harm.
  • Unjust enrichment was established, as Briggs paid $10,200 in retainer fees but received no lawful services.
  • The corporate veil was pierced, holding Alessandro personally liable for Law Help Ltd.’s misconduct.

• Damages Awarded:

  • Compensatory Damages: $20,285 for lost retainers, legal costs, fines, and transcript orders.
  • Aggravated and Punitive Damages: $25,000 for emotional distress and to deter similar misconduct.
  • Disbursements: $2,498.52, plus pre- and post-judgment interest.
  • Total: $47,783.52.

2024 ONSC 6489

• Costs Determination:
  • Following Briggs’ success in the default judgment motion, costs were assessed.
  • Alessandro’s obstructive litigation tactics and failure to comply with procedures increased costs.
  • The court awarded Briggs $15,000 in costs, recognizing the importance of pro bono legal work in promoting access to justice.

Final Outcome Across Both Decisions:

• Total Award to Briggs: $62,783.52, including damages, disbursements, and costs.
• The rulings emphasized Alessandro’s egregious conduct and provided both financial compensation to Briggs and punitive measures to deter similar actions in the future.