The Decorators Choice Paint Store Ltd. v. Innes Crossing Inc.
The Decorators Choice Paint Store Ltd.
Law Firm / Organization
Borden Ladner Gervais LLP (BLG)
Innes Crossing Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Unrepresented

Key Points:

  • Background:
    • The Decorators Choice has leased space from Innes Crossing for over 20 years.
    • A new lease for a larger space was signed on February 1, 2022.
    • Innes Crossing failed to complete required construction work and did not provide possession by June 1, 2022.
  • Default Judgment Motion:
    • Innes Crossing did not respond to the statement of claim and was noted in default.
    • The Decorators Choice sought validation of the lease, specific performance, and an adjournment of the damages claim until fully crystallized.
  • Court's Findings:
    • Lease Execution: The lease was validly executed.
    • Breach of Lease: Innes Crossing breached the lease by not completing required work and not providing possession of the new premises.
    • Specific Performance: Granted because the property is unique and monetary damages are inadequate. The new premises allow business growth and fulfillment of distributor agreements.
    • Adjournment of Damages Claim: Damages will be addressed once The Decorators Choice has taken possession and completed necessary work.
  • Disposition:
    • The lease was validly executed and breached by Innes Crossing.
    • Specific performance of the lease is granted for the full term of 10 years.
    • Innes Crossing must give immediate possession and facilitate necessary work and permits.
    • The damages claim is adjourned until losses are fully crystallized.
    • Costs will be considered later.

 

Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-23-93941
Real estate
Plaintiff