Background: John Pyper appealed a decision where Katy Schuetze had successfully sued him for battery. In November 2021, Justice Fleming found Pyper had committed a serious battery against Schuetze, awarding her approximately $798,000 in damages.

Legal Arguments/Issues: Pyper attempted to appeal various orders, including the award of partial special costs. His appeal was partially successful, reducing some costs but still upholding the main judgment. Pyper also challenged the disclosure of documents related to Schuetze's contingency fee agreement, arguing it was necessary to assess the reasonableness of the legal fees. Multiple courts, including Justice Whately and Justice Fitch, dismissed these appeals, upholding the protection of solicitor-client privilege and finding no merit in Pyper’s claims.

Court’s Decision: Pyper's application to vary or cancel an order denying him leave to appeal was dismissed. The Court noted Pyper’s repeated and unfounded appeals as a form of legal harassment, potentially amounting to family violence. The delay caused by his appeals was found to prejudice Schuetze, particularly in the assessment of special costs.

Award/Costs: Schuetze was awarded approximately $798,000 in damages. The Court also granted her costs in the appeal proceedings, further penalizing Pyper for his persistent and meritless legal actions.