The Bank of Nova Scotia v. Rosario Rosado
THE BANK OF NOVA SCOTIA
Law Firm / Organization
Spetter Zeitz Klaiman PC
Lawyer(s)

Cora Madden

CARLOS MANUEL ROSARIO ROSADO also known as CARLOS-MANUEL ROSARIO-ROSADO
Law Firm / Organization
Unrepresented

Facts

  • March 2022: The Bank advanced a $350,000 professional student line of credit to the Defendant.
  • The Defendant fraudulently claimed enrollment in the Doctor of Dental Surgery program at the University of Toronto, providing falsified documents.
  • Defaulted on the loan, owing $355,357.41 as of December 2022.
  • The Bank sought repayment and punitive damages for fraud.

Legal Proceedings

  • The Defendant did not respond, leading to default judgment.
  • Rule 19.02(1)(a) deemed the Defendant to admit all allegations by default.

Court Findings

  • Fraud Proven: False representation, knowledge of falsehood, reliance by the Bank, and suffered losses.
  • Punitive Damages: $200,000 awarded for malicious, premeditated fraud.
  • Additional Orders:
    • Accounting of all monies received by the Defendant.
    • Disgorgement of funds and profits from fraud.
    • Preservation of the Bank's right to choose between a constructive trust and damages.
  • Costs: Substantial indemnity costs of $13,094 awarded to the Plaintiff.

Disposition

  • Ordered payment of $355,357.41 plus interest.
  • Punitive damages of $200,000.
  • Substantial indemnity costs of $13,094.
    • Total: $568,451.41 (excluding interest)
  • Accounting and disgorgement of fraudulently obtained funds.
  • Preservation of the Bank's right to elect between a constructive trust and damages.

 

Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-23-805-00
Civil litigation
$ 568,451
Plaintiff