Flight (Heritage Painters & Services) v. Bank of Nova Scotia
Brian Wayne Flight c.o.b. as Heritage Painters & Services
Law Firm / Organization
Kronis, Rotsztain, Margles, Cappel LLP
Lawyer(s)

Joe Wahba

The Bank of Nova Scotia
Law Firm / Organization
Remote Law Canada
Lawyer(s)

Tara Vasdani

Julie Leblanc
Law Firm / Organization
Lerners LLP
Lawyer(s)

Jason Squire

Background:

  • Mr. Flight's Allegations:
    • Claims his former spouse and bookkeeper, Julie Leblanc, misappropriated over $200,000 using a power of attorney.
    • Filed multiple lawsuits related to these claims, including against Ms. Leblanc, a trustee in bankruptcy, and the Bank.
  • Previous Legal Actions:
    • The initial lawsuit against Ms. Leblanc was dismissed due to Mr. Flight's status as an undischarged bankrupt.
    • Subsequent actions included suing the trustee in bankruptcy and the Bank.

Motion Judge's Decision:

  • The Bank's motion to strike Mr. Flight's statement of claim and dismiss the action was granted.
  • Key Reasons:
    • The action was considered a collateral attack on a previous court ruling.
    • The claim was time-barred based on the knowledge of the alleged fraud by January 2018.

Appeal and Analysis:

  • The Bank sought an order for Mr. Flight to post security for costs.
  • Findings:
    • Mr. Flight's appeal appeared frivolous and vexatious.
    • Mr. Flight lacked sufficient assets in Ontario to cover the Bank's costs.
    • It was just to require security for costs given Mr. Flight’s repeated litigation on the same issues.

Orders:

  1. Security for Costs:
    • Mr. Flight must post $25,000 by May 27, 2024, or face dismissal of his appeal.
  2. Further Steps:
    • Mr. Flight cannot proceed with the appeal until the security is posted.
  3. Costs:
    • The Bank awarded partial indemnity costs of $4,000.

 

Court of Appeal for Ontario
COA-24-CV-0252; M55056
Bankruptcy & insolvency
$ 29,000
Defendant