Jiujias v. Lau
Theodore Jiujias
Michael Chun Ho Lau
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Aaron Storr
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
ASML Holdings Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified

Key Points:

  • Motion: Plaintiff seeks an order to issue a Certificate of Pending Litigation (CPL) against the property at 194 Torrens Avenue, Toronto.
  • Background:
    • In 2020, Jiujias loaned money to Lau and Mortgage Impression Corp. (MIC), secured by a mortgage on two properties.
    • Lau and MIC defaulted on the mortgage, leading to power of sale proceedings. One property was sold, and a deficiency of $414,533.43 remained after the second property was sold.
    • Jiujias commenced the First Mortgage Action against Lau and MIC, which was not defended by Lau. Subsequently, a fraudulent transfer of the property by Lau to Storr and ASML was alleged.

Legal Analysis:

  • Requirements for CPL:
    • Interest in land is in question.
    • High probability of success in the main action.
    • Evidence of intent to defeat or delay creditors.
    • Balance of convenience favors issuing a CPL.

Court Findings:

  • High Probability of Success: Likely for Jiujias to obtain judgment due to Lau's failure to defend.
  • Intent to Defeat Creditors: Evidence of fraudulent intent through transfer for less than market value, close relationship between parties, significant liabilities at the time, and secretive nature of the transfer.
  • Balance of Convenience: If CPL is not granted, the sale of the property would dissipate the equity, prejudicing Jiujias' claim.

Conclusion:

  • Order Granted: Leave to issue a CPL on the property at 194 Torrens Avenue.
  • Actions Required: Plaintiff must serve motion materials to the defendants, parties registered on title, and attempt to serve the intended purchasers of the property.
  • The document does not specify a total monetary award
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-24-00722428-0000
Real estate
Plaintiff