Tri-South Developments Inc. v. 583167 Ontario Inc.
Tri-South Developments Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Lenczner Slaght LLP
583167 Ontario Inc.

Facts

  • Contribution Agreement (CA): The parties agreed to develop a 41-storey condominium. The Plaintiff needed to obtain land severance by a specific date but failed.
  • Dispute: The Plaintiff alleged the Defendant misled them about the severance date's importance, continuing the project and waiving termination rights.

Issues

  1. Good Faith and Honest Performance: Did the Defendant breach its duty?
  2. Waiver: Did the Defendant waive the severance condition?
  3. Unjust Enrichment: Was the Defendant unjustly enriched by the Plaintiff's efforts?

Court Findings

  • Good Faith: The Defendant did not breach its duty. The Plaintiff ignored the severance date and did not fulfill its obligation.
  • Waiver: The Defendant did not waive the severance condition. No clear intention to waive was demonstrated.
  • Unjust Enrichment: The Defendant was not unjustly enriched, as the Plaintiff’s expenses were part of their contractual obligations.

Decision

  • Outcome: The court dismissed the Plaintiff’s action.
  • Costs: The parties were encouraged to agree on costs or submit written submissions if an agreement could not be reached. No monetary award specified.

 

Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-21-00665510-0000
Real estate
Defendant