2624221 Ontario Inc. v. Matsvayai et al.
2624221 ONTARIO INC.
Law Firm / Organization
Agueci & Calabretta
FLEXPARK INC.
Law Firm / Organization
Agueci & Calabretta
MATSVAYI, LUCIA
Lawyer(s)

Ethan Rogers

MADZIMA, BLENDEN
Lawyer(s)

Ethan Rogers

WESTHAVEN INCOME INC.
Law Firm / Organization
Agueci & Calabretta
LUIGI LATTO
Law Firm / Organization
Agueci & Calabretta
FLEXPARK INC.
Law Firm / Organization
Agueci & Calabretta
PETER GROCCIA
Law Firm / Organization
Agueci & Calabretta
ROSA GROCCIA
Law Firm / Organization
Agueci & Calabretta
SABINE QUATTROCIOCCHI aka BARRAGAN aka SABINE PUCCIARELLI
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
GABRIEL BRUTTO
Law Firm / Organization
Gardiner Roberts LLP
Lawyer(s)

Allison Farley

BRUTTO LAW PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION
Law Firm / Organization
Gardiner Roberts LLP
Lawyer(s)

Allison Farley

DI MAURO LAW PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION
Law Firm / Organization
Kestenberg Litigation LLP
Lawyer(s)

Marc Kestenberg

2666906 ONTARIO INC .
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
SANDRA DE BARTOLO
Law Firm / Organization
Kestenberg Litigation LLP
Lawyer(s)

Marc Kestenberg

RAMESH SRIVASTAVA aka GARRY SRIVASTAVA
DSMNK INVESTMENT GROUP LTD.
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified

Key Points

  • Mortgages:
    • $650,000 by DSMNK (assigned to Flexpark) against 85 Twin Willow Crescent.
    • $330,000 by 2624221 Ontario Inc. (Westhaven) against the same property.
  • Summary Judgment Motions: Address defaults on the mortgages.
  • Claims:
    • Plaintiffs seek to enforce the mortgage agreements.
    • Defendants allege fraud and misrepresentation, counterclaiming against multiple parties for collusion.

Court Orders

  • Summary Judgment:
    • Granted for Flexpark and Westhaven, enforcement stayed pending counterclaim trial.
  • Counterclaims:
    • Counterclaims against Flexpark, Westhaven, Luigi Lato, Peter Groccia, and Rosa Groccia proceed to trial.
    • Counterclaims against Sandra De Bartolo and Di Mauro Law dismissed.

Legal Findings

  • Genuine Issue for Trial: Required for allegations of conspiracy and fraud, but not for mortgage payment obligations.
  • Unconscionable Transactions Relief Act: Insufficient evidence to relieve mortgage obligations.
  • Duty of Care: Lawyers for the lenders owed no duty to the defendants, leading to dismissal of related counterclaims.

Conclusion

Summary judgment was granted to the plaintiffs for the mortgage amounts but stayed pending the counterclaims trial. Some counterclaims will proceed to trial, while others were dismissed.

Total Monetary Award:

  • Flexpark Inc.: $773,297.82 plus interest at 8% per annum from March 24, 2022, and legal fees.
  • Westhaven Income Inc.: $498,345.20 plus interest accruing at 14% per annum from January 22, 2024, and legal fees.

The total monetary award granted to Flexpark and Westhaven is $1,271,643.02, excluding the accruing interest and legal fees.

 

Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-20-2084-0000
Real estate
$ 1,271,643
Plaintiff