Roger Vanden Berghe NV v. Korhani of Canada Inc
Roger Vanden Berghe NV in liquidation by its liquidator, Rik Crivit
Law Firm / Organization
Chaitons LLP
Lawyer(s)

Darren Marr

Korhani of Canada Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Pettle Law
Lawyer(s)

Micheal J. Pettle

Case Background:

  • RVB, a Belgian company, sold textiles to Korhani, a Canadian company.
  • Korhani failed to pay invoices totaling approximately €2,663 and USD $167,735.50.
  • The Belgian court granted RVB a judgment against Korhani, which Korhani did not respond to or appeal.

Legal Issues:

  • Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Judgments: The court evaluates whether the Belgian judgment can be enforced in Ontario.
  • Defenses Raised by Korhani: Korhani disputes the amounts owed and argues against the Belgian court's jurisdiction and the procedural fairness of the Belgian proceedings.

Court's Analysis:

  • Jurisdiction: The Belgian court had a real and substantial connection to the dispute, as the contracts were processed and governed under Belgian law.
  • Final and Conclusive Judgment: The Belgian judgment is final and for a definite sum of money.
  • Defenses:
    • Natural Justice: No evidence suggests that Korhani was denied a fair process.
    • Fraud: Disputing amounts does not equate to proving fraud.
    • Public Policy: Not applicable as there were no fundamental moral issues.

Conclusion:

  • The Ontario Superior Court of Justice enforces the Belgian judgment.
  • Korhani is ordered to pay the Canadian dollar equivalent of the Belgian judgment amount.
  • RVB is awarded interest as per the Belgian judgment.
  • Costs: Korhani to pay RVB's legal costs amounting to $10,383.59 within 30 days.

Important Points:

  • Foreign judgments are recognized if rendered by a competent jurisdiction and meet Canadian standards of natural justice and fairness.
  • Mere disputing of amounts or procedural claims without evidence does not prevent enforcement.
  • Costs awarded were deemed reasonable and necessary by the court.

 

Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-22-00683305-0000
Corporate & commercial law
$ 10,384
Applicant