2 Jul 2024
Vistoli v. Haventree Bank
Background:
- Plaintiff's Allegation: Haventree Bank automatically renewed her mortgage at a higher interest rate (9.99%) without her consent, causing her financial hardship and leading to the sale of her property.
- Legal Basis: Breach of the Interest Act and contractual terms due to involuntary/automatic mortgage renewals.
Proceedings:
- Class Certification: Action certified for settlement purposes on April 2, 2024.
- Class Definition: Individuals in Canada whose mortgages were involuntarily or automatically renewed by Haventree Bank, incurring additional interest, costs, and fees.
- Settlement Approval Hearing: No objections or opt-outs were received.
Settlement Details:
- Total Settlement Amount: $1,500,000
- Eligible Class Members: Approximately 3,340
- Individual Compensation: Up to $5,000 per mortgage, based on the take-up rate.
- Excess Funds: To be donated to a cy-près recipient approved by the court.
Court Findings:
- Fairness of Settlement: The settlement was deemed fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of the class.
- Class Counsel Fees: Approved at $450,000 plus HST and disbursements.
- Honorarium: Requested honorarium of $15,000 for the representative plaintiff was not approved due to the absence of exceptional circumstances.
Legal Principles Applied:
- Settlement Approval: Governed by the Class Proceedings Act, requiring court approval to ensure the settlement is fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of the class.
- Class Counsel Fees: Evaluated based on the contingency fee agreement, actual fees incurred, and principles set out in previous case law.
Orders:
- Settlement approved.
- Continued appointment of Epiq as Claims Administrator approved.
- Notice Plan and Notice of Settlement Approval approved.
- Claim Form approved.
- Class counsel fees approved.
- Honorarium request denied.