Charles (Litigation Guardian of) v. Gore Mutual Insurance Company
JAHSIAH-CHANCE CHARLES, by his Litigation Guardian, Shernelle Charles
Law Firm / Organization
Diamond and Diamond Lawyers LLP
Lawyer(s)

Tania Fleming

GORE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified

Key Points:

  • Nature of the Case:
    • Application to approve a settlement for accident benefits under Rule 7.08 of the Rules of Civil Procedure.
    • The applicant, a minor, sustained significant injuries (ankle, wrist fracture, concussion) in a motor vehicle accident on September 17, 2021.
    • The settlement includes future medical/rehabilitation benefits and non-earner benefits (NEBs).
  • Legal Representatives:
    • Applicant’s Counsel: Tania Fleming (paralegal).
  • Proceedings:
    • The application was submitted in writing and required court approval due to the minor status of the applicant.

Court's Findings and Requirements:

  • Deficiencies Noted:
    • The affidavit supporting the settlement was from a paralegal, not a lawyer, contrary to the requirements of Rule 7.08.
    • Missing essential documentation, such as:
      • A lawyer’s affidavit.
      • Proposed minutes of settlement.
      • Detailed explanations regarding NEBs and Attendant Care benefits.
      • Current status and impact of the minor’s injuries and treatment.
  • Additional Information Required:
    • Detailed affidavit by a lawyer.
    • Explanation and justification of the settlement's fairness and why it is in the minor's best interest.
    • Clarification on the minor’s ongoing impairments and school performance.
    • Status and specifics of any related tort claim.
    • Dockets or detailed account of work completed on the case.
  • Next Steps:
    • The motion is adjourned to January 8, 2024, for a written hearing.
    • Additional materials and affidavits must be submitted in compliance with the Rules of Civil Procedure.
  • No monetary award was specified in the decision.
  • The document does not explicitly state the final successful party because the court has not yet approved the settlement.
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-23-00709358-0000
Insurance law