Kearney v. Collard Properties Inc.
Sean Kearney
Law Firm / Organization
Brazeau Seller Law
Lawyer(s)

Geoffrey Cullwick

Collard Properties Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified

Overview: Sean Kearney applied to register a May 6, 2024, judgment from the New Brunswick Court of King's Bench. The application, made without notice to Collard Properties Inc., was granted.

Key Points:

  1. Application without Notice:
    • Under s. 2(2) of the Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments Act, notice isn’t required if the debtor had notice of the original proceedings or submitted to the original court’s jurisdiction.
    • Collard Properties initiated the original proceeding, agreed to settlement terms, appeared in enforcement motions, and consented to the judgment.
  2. Criteria for Registration:
    • Judgments from reciprocating states can be registered unless exceptions in s. 3 of the Act apply.
    • Jurisdiction: The New Brunswick court had jurisdiction over the dispute involving 720434 N.B. Inc.
    • Business Presence: Collard Properties conducted business in New Brunswick and participated in court proceedings.
    • Fraud: No evidence of fraud; judgment was consensual.
    • Appeal: No pending appeal.
    • Public Policy: The cause of action would be valid in Ontario.
    • Defence: Collard Properties consented to the judgment and would not have a valid defence.
  3. Order and Costs:
    • The New Brunswick judgment is registered under the Reciprocal Enforcement of Judgments Act.
    • Notice of registration must be given to Collard Properties within one month, allowing them to apply to set it aside within another month.
    • Costs of $5,585.64 were awarded to Mr. Kearney on a partial indemnity basis.

Conclusion: The application for registering the New Brunswick judgment is granted, affirming reciprocal enforcement of judgments and due process.

 

Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
24-95880
Corporate & commercial law
$ 5,586
Applicant