Roy-Noel v. Buckle
Shelley Ann Roy-Noel
Law Firm / Organization
Parsons Corrin LLP
Mark Buckle and Dale Buckle as Administrators of the Estate of Christopher Mark Buckle
Law Firm / Organization
Unrepresented
Insurance Corporation of British Columbia
Law Firm / Organization
Paine Edmonds LLP

Background: The case addresses Shelley Ann Roy-Noel's claims for damages resulting from injuries sustained in a car accident caused by Christopher Mark Buckle. Liability was not contested, as ICBC acted as the de facto defendant following the non-response of the administrators of Christopher Buckle's estate. The medical evidence supported the plaintiff's claims of significant physical and psychological injuries, leading to her inability to work full-time and the necessity for ongoing medical interventions. The injuries and conditions included chronic pain, migrainous headaches, light and sound sensitivity, tinnitus, hearing loss, and various psychological conditions such as PTSD and major depressive disorder.

Held: The court recognized the profound impact of the collision on Roy-Noel's health and quality of life, resulting in permanent disabilities and an inability to return to her previous professional and personal activities. The awarded damages reflect the severity of the injuries and the permanent effects they will have on the plaintiff's ability to lead her previous life and earn a living.

Costs/Damages Awarded:

  • Total Award: The court ordered a total of $1,945,857 in damages to Roy-Noel.
  • Non-pecuniary damages: $250,000
  • Past wage loss/loss of past earning capacity: $151,098 (gross)
  • Loss of future earning capacity: $950,000
  • Cost of future care: $584,073
  • Special damages: $10,686
Supreme Court of British Columbia
M198738
Personal injury law
$ 1,945,857
Plaintiff