Background Facts: Mr. Meneray was involved in an off-duty incident where he punched a cyclist and shared details on social media. The BC SPCA initiated an investigation, during which Mr. Meneray recorded confidential discussions, leading to his termination for cause. He grieved the termination, and the matter was set for arbitration.

Judicial Review of SPCA's Actions: The key issue was whether the BC SPCA's disciplinary decision should have been handled under the Police Act or the Collective Agreement. The petitioner challenged the procedures followed after the incident, arguing that disciplinary action should have followed the Police Act and Special Provincial Constable Complaint Procedure Regulation.

Judicial Review of Minister's Actions: The Minister closed Mr. Meneray’s Special Provincial Constable appointment, which the petitioner challenged as unreasonable and improper.

Costs/Damages Awarded: The judgment did not specify costs or awards in favor of any party in the provided excerpt??.