First Source Financial Management v. Chacon Strawberry Fields Inc.
First Source Financial Management Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP
Lawyer(s)

Ryan Shah

Chacon Strawberry Fields Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
S and S Lawyers LLP
Law Firm / Organization
Daoust Vukovich LLP
Lawyer(s)

Wolfgang Kaufmann

SURINDER KAUR CHAHAL
Law Firm / Organization
Daoust Vukovich LLP
Lawyer(s)

Wolfgang Kaufmann

Law Firm / Organization
S and S Lawyers LLP
The Fuller Landau Group Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Aird & Berlis LLP
1794523 Ontario Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Bridge Law Professional Corporation
Lawyer(s)

Jitesh Bhalla

Ramesh Ahluwalia
Law Firm / Organization
MMD Law Firm
Lawyer(s)

Arnab Bose

Key Issues

  1. Receiver’s Motion:

    • Approval of sale process and transaction.
    • Approval and vesting order.
    • Approval of Receiver's reports, fees, disbursements, and interim distribution to the first secured creditor.
  2. Respondents' Requests:

    • Adjournment of the motion to secure financing.
    • Access to confidential sale documents.
  3. Third-Party Bidder’s Claim:

    • Consideration of a late offer made after the sale agreement.

Background

  • Parties:
    • Applicant: First Source Financial Management Inc. (secured creditor).
    • Respondent: Chacon Strawberry Fields Inc. (owner of a retail plaza).
    • Receiver: Fuller Landau Group Inc.
  • Property: A fully leased retail plaza in Caledon, Ontario.
  • Timeline:
    • Receiver appointed: July 19, 2024.
    • Marketing and bidding process: September to November 2024.
    • Purchaser's bid accepted: November 13, 2024.

Court's Findings

  1. Adjournment Request Denied:

    • The respondents failed to demonstrate sufficient financial readiness to redeem mortgages.
    • Delays could undermine the integrity of the court-approved sales process.
  2. Sale Process Upheld:

    • The process followed principles from Royal Bank of Canada v. Soundair Corp..
    • Marketing was comprehensive, and the Purchaser’s bid was highest and unconditional.
  3. Late Bid Rejected:

    • Accepting bids post-deadline undermines fairness and the process’s integrity.
  4. Approval and Vesting Order Granted:

    • The sale to the Purchaser approved, extinguishing prior encumbrances.
  5. Interim Distribution Approved:

    • $16 million to First Source as the first-ranking secured creditor.
  6. Sealing Order Granted:

    • Confidential transaction details sealed to protect commercial interests.
  7. Other Relief Approved:

    • Receiver’s reports and fees found reasonable and necessary.

Conclusion

  • The Receiver’s motion was fully granted. 
  • No damages or costs were awarded explicitly as this was a receivership matter focused on asset disposition and creditor repayment
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-24-00717742-00CL
Corporate & commercial law
Other
03 April 2024