2 Apr 2024
Galaxy Communities Inc. v. Chelliah
Background:
- Galaxy Communities Inc. (Galaxy) sold a property in Highland Creek, Scarborough, to Prabhaharan Chelliah and Sobitha Arunakirinathan (the Owners) and contracted to build their house. A dispute arose over the construction quality, leading to legal action.
Legal Issues:
- Whether the construction work by Galaxy was deficient or incomplete.
- If so, whether Galaxy breached the construction contract.
- The quantum of damages owed to the Owners due to any breach.
Court’s Analysis and Decision:
- The court found that Galaxy breached the contract by failing to complete the work in accordance with the agreed specifications and by performing deficiently.
- Despite Galaxy’s non-appearance at trial, the Owners presented unchallenged evidence of deficiencies and incomplete work.
- The court relied on expert testimony and other evidence to assess the deficiencies and calculate damages.
- Galaxy’s failure to comply with court orders and its withdrawal of a lien on the trial's commencement day were noted.
Outcome:
- Galaxy was found liable for delayed and deficient performance, with damages awarded to Mr. Chelliah amounting to $288,577.10, inclusive of HST and pre-judgment interest.
- Costs were awarded to the Owners in the amount of $45,282.27, including HST and disbursements.