Street v. Sather Ranch Ltd.
Michael Neil Street
Law Firm / Organization
Dvorak Litigation Services
Lawyer(s)

Steven Dvorak

Marielle Jacqueline Angella Brule
Law Firm / Organization
Dvorak Litigation Services
Lawyer(s)

Steven Dvorak

Sather Ranch Ltd. by its Court Appointed Receiver and Manager, C. Cheveldave & Associates Ltd.
Law Firm / Organization
Lawson Lundell LLP
Lawyer(s)

Noor Mann

  • Facts: Sather Ranch Ltd. (SRL), in receivership, faces claims from Michael Street and others, relating to a feud between Street and Joseph Sather. The case revolves around the validity of claims against SRL, involving property transactions and financial contributions to the corporation.

  • Issue: The court needed to determine the validity of the financial claims made against SRL by various parties, examining if these were approved, benefited SRL, were fair in value, and not part of any improper scheme.

  • Court's Ruling: The court approved the claims of Michael Neil Street, Boundary Machine Ltd., Marielle Jacqueline Angella Brule, and Profectus Financial Inc. against SRL, finding them valid and made in good faith. It rejected most of the Sather Claimants' claims due to inadequate documentation and substantiation.

  • Amount of Costs/Damages Awarded:

    • Michael Neil Street: $143,201.22
    • Boundary Machine Ltd.: $515,712.83
    • Marielle Jacqueline Angella Brule: $8,000.00
    • Profectus Financial Inc.: $36,158.00
    • Joseph Sather and AMX Real Estate Inc.: $77,750.00
    • Each amount plus interest calculated at 5% per annum from August 7, 2018, to the date of the order.
Supreme Court of British Columbia
S1913131
Corporate & commercial law
$ 780,822
Plaintiff