Chan v. Liang
Timothy Rudolph Kam Bong Chan
Law Firm / Organization
Lawson Lundell LLP
Carmine Yuk Kam Lee
Law Firm / Organization
Lawson Lundell LLP
Shih Ju Liang
Law Firm / Organization
Self Represented
Shan Zhou
Law Firm / Organization
Self Represented
  • Facts: The case involves a dispute between neighbors over a property line and the construction of a fence that one party claims encroaches on their property.
  • Issue: The main legal issue is whether the fence constructed by one neighbor trespasses onto the other neighbor's property, constituting a nuisance.
  • Court's Ruling: The court found in favor of the plaintiff, determining that the fence indeed trespassed onto the plaintiff's property and ordered its removal or modification to comply with legal property boundaries.
  • Costs/Damages Awarded: The total damages awarded to the successful party, the plaintiffs, in the case "Chan v. Liang" amounted to $21,050. This total comprises:
    • General damages of $10,000 for loss of privacy, loss of use and enjoyment of their property, and for the harassment endured by them and their contractors.
    • Special damages of $1,050 for the cost of a second survey that was deemed necessary by the plaintiffs but disputed by the defendants.
    • Punitive damages of $10,000 awarded due to the defendants' behavior which the court found to be not just inappropriate but also malicious and escalating.
Supreme Court of British Columbia
S2210114
Civil litigation
$ 21,050
Plaintiff