Highland Cannabis Inc. v. Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario
Highland Cannabis Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Kelly & Co.
Lawyer(s)

Brian Kelly

Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
High Tide Inc.
Law Firm / Organization
Dale & Lessmann LLP
Lawyer(s)

Jeffrey P. Hoffman

  • Context: This case pertains to a data breach at AGCO involving sales data of cannabis retailers, which Highland Cannabis alleges was misused by High Tide Inc.

Key Allegations by Plaintiff:

  • Highland Cannabis claims High Tide used leaked sales data to gain a competitive advantage, proposing to purchase Highland's store based on this data and strategically opening a new store location.
  • The Plaintiff asserts two torts against High Tide:
    1. Intrusion upon seclusion - unauthorized access to private information.
    2. Conversion - wrongful possession and use of the plaintiff's sales data.

Court's Findings:

  • Intrusion upon Seclusion:
    • The court found no intentional or reckless act by High Tide to access the breached data.
    • High Tide was also a victim of the data breach, having its own sales data leaked.
    • The Plaintiff's distress or anguish from the use of the data was not evident or supported.
  • Conversion:
    • The court ruled that conversion does not apply to intangible property like data.
    • There was no unlawful act by High Tide that denied the Plaintiff's rights to its data.

Conclusion:

  • The court dismissed the action against High Tide, stating the claims were "frivolous and vexatious."
  • It was deemed "plain and obvious" that the Plaintiff's claims had no reasonable prospect of success.

Outcome:

  • The claims against High Tide Inc. were dismissed. The case remains against the AGCO.

 

Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-23-12
Corporate & commercial law
Defendant