Covach v. Grand River Natural Stone Ltd.
Robert Covach
Grand River Natural Stone Ltd.
Law Firm / Organization
SimpsonWigle Law LLP
Lawyer(s)

Maryam Samani

Key Points / Takeaways:

  • Robert Covach appealed a Small Claims Court decision ordering him to pay $22,853.53 plus interest and costs to Grand River Natural Stone Ltd.
  • Covach argued the Deputy Judge failed to provide sufficient reasons regarding the material type, nature, or color provided.
  • The Divisional Court found the Deputy Judge's reasons sufficient, emphasizing Covach used the materials, indicating satisfaction.

Ruling:

  • The appeal was dismissed, affirming the Small Claims Court's decision.

Amount Awarded:

  • Costs of $10,000 all-inclusive awarded to Grand River Natural Stone Ltd. for the appeal.
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
DC-23-201
Civil litigation
$ 10,000
Respondent