Situmorang v. Google, LLC
Yeremia Situmorang
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Google, LLC
  • Issue: Appeal against dismissal of class action certification and action itself, claiming Google's use of facial recognition technology in Google Photos without consent violates privacy laws and consumer protection legislation.
  • Ruling: Appeal allowed. The court found errors in the chambers judge's characterization and dismissal of claims, ruling that the notice of civil claim discloses a cause of action under the British Columbia Privacy Act and common law tort of intrusion upon seclusion. The case was remitted for amendment regarding consumer protection claims.
  • Key Points:
    • The judge erred by mischaracterizing the nature of claims and not assuming pleaded facts as true.
    • The use of facial recognition technology without consent was deemed potentially violative of privacy rights.
    • The appellant was granted the opportunity to amend the claim, particularly concerning consumer protection legislation deficiencies.
  • Amount Awarded: Not applicable as the case was remitted for further proceedings regarding the amendment of claims.
Court of Appeals for British Columbia
CA48774
Corporate & commercial law
Appellant