20 Nov 2023
Cavanaugh v. Grenville Christian College
- Date of the case: November 20, 2023
- Parties involved: Plaintiffs, including Representative Plaintiffs Lisa Cavanaugh, Andrew Hale-Byrne, Richard Van Dusen, Margaret Granger, and Tim Blacklock, and Defendants associated with Grenville Christian College.
- Financial award/costs:
- Settlement Amount: $10,875,000.00
- Class Counsel’s Fees: $3,122,187.50
- Class Proceedings Fund’s Levy: $736,531.25
- Honoraria Payments to Representative Plaintiffs: $7,500 each
- Key points by subcategory:
A. Introduction:
- The case was brought under the Class Proceedings Act, 1992.
- A settlement agreement was reached after various legal proceedings.
Factual Background:
- Abuse claims by students who attended Grenville Christian College between 1973 and 1997.
- The college closed in 2007 with limited assets and multiple insurance providers.
- The action was commenced in 2008.
- Retainer agreements were in place between Plaintiffs and Class Counsel.
- Indemnification had been obtained for adverse costs awards.
- Coverage issues existed with insurance policies.
- The certification and appeals process had occurred.
- The common issues trial took place in 2019.
- Findings of systemic negligence and breach of fiduciary duties had been made.
- The Ontario Court of Appeal affirmed the trial judgment in 2021.
- Efforts to establish a procedure for the individual issues phase had been made.
Conclusion:
- The motion was approved, except for granting honorariums.