This was a federal case. The appellants were Binal Patel and Balsam Spa dba Balsam Day Spa, while the respondents were Dermaspark Products Inc. and Pollogen Ltd. The respondents had a trademark over a machine known as OxyGeneo machine, which was bought by Balsam Spa, along with certain products that were used to operate with the machine, from an online seller. This was a challenge arising from an order that ordered substantial damages, along with punitive damages. The hearing was set on Dec. 5, 2023. No financial award was specified.