IBM Canada Limited v. Dario Ceci and Jacinthe Ratelle
IBM CANADA LIMITED
Law Firm / Organization
Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP
Lawyer(s)

David Andrew Stamp

DARIO CECI
Law Firm / Organization
Independent
Lawyer(s)

Ari Nathan Kaplan

JACINTHE RATELLE
Law Firm / Organization
Independent
Lawyer(s)

Ari Nathan Kaplan

Background:

  • IBM Canada Limited sought rectification of its pension plan to correct drafting mistakes made in 2014, affecting the accrual of pension benefits for employees on disability leave.

Issues:

  1. Rectification of drafting errors in the IBM pension plan.
  2. Whether these errors resulted in unintended pension accrual rules.

Decision:

  • The court granted rectification, acknowledging the mistakes were unintended and resulted from miscommunication between IBM and its service provider.

Key Details:

  • The errors extended the age for pension accrual during disability from 55 to 65, not intended by IBM.
  • IBM consistently administered the plan as if the errors had not been made, signaling no intention to change pension accrual rules.
  • The court ordered the pension plan's language to be corrected as it stood between January 1, 2014, and June 30, 2019.

Outcome:

  • The pension plan was to be rectified to reflect IBM's original intent and administrative practices.
  • Costs were neither sought nor awarded in the decision.
Superior Court of Justice - Ontario
CV-23-00698308-00CL
Pensions & benefits law
$ 0
Applicant
19 September 2019