Li Estate (Trustee) v Li
Crowe MacKay & Company Ltd., in its capacity as Trustee of the Estate of Xiao Bo Li, a Bankrupt
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Clinton Li
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

J.E. Roos

Danny Ting Chung Ma
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

J.E. Roos

  • Background: The case involves a dispute between the Li Estate (Trustee) as Plaintiff and Clinton Li and Danny Ting Chung Ma as Defendants, regarding a property in Vancouver.

  • Plaintiff’s Claim: The Trustee alleged that profits from a property sale were used by Ms. Li and Mr. Ma to purchase another property, which was later transferred to Mr. Li. The Trustee claimed a resulting trust against Mr. Li for half interest in this property.

  • Defendants' Position: The Defendants applied for cancellation of a certificate of pending litigation (CPL) against their property, arguing it hindered planned development. They proposed an undertaking for damages as sufficient security.

  • Court's Decision:

    • The Court found the Plaintiff’s claim against Mr. Li for a resulting trust in the property likely to succeed.
    • An undertaking was deemed insufficient for security.
    • The Court ordered cancellation of the CPL upon posting security in the amount of $857,831.72, half of the sale proceeds of the initial property.
  • Costs:

    • The Plaintiff was successful on the issue before the Court.
    • The Court awarded costs in the cause to the Plaintiff.
  • Conclusion: The Court emphasized the strength of the Plaintiff’s claim and the insufficiency of an undertaking as security, requiring a substantial amount to be posted for cancellation of the CPL and awarding costs to the Plaintiff.

Supreme Court of British Columbia
S228684
Real estate
$ 857,832
Plaintiff