9219-1568 QUEBEC INC. ET AL v. PRIVACY COMMISSIONER OF CANADA
9219-1568 QUEBEC INC
MG FREESITES LTD
PRIVACY COMMISSIONER OF CANADA
Law Firm / Organization
Government
  • Applicants: 9219-1568 Quebec Inc. and MG Freesites Ltd.
  • Requested Relief:
    • Stay of the Privacy Commissioner's final report's publication until judicial review resolution.
    • Continuation of confidentiality order and publication ban on investigation details until judicial review resolution?.
  • Motion Support: Relied on Andreas Alkiviades Andreou's affidavit?.
  • Main Issues:
    • Whether an interim injunction should be issued.
    • Continuation of confidentiality order and publication ban.
  • Interim Injunction Criteria: Serious issue to be tried, irreparable harm if not granted, balance of convenience favoring injunction?.
  • MindGeek's Arguments:
    • Commissioner's delay in report publication, investigation timeliness, and jurisdiction over foreign conduct?.
    • Claimed irreparable harm to reputation and judicial review rights from report publication, but lacked specific evidence?.
  • Public Interest Consideration: Weighed heavily in favor of Commissioner performing statutory duties under PIPEDA?.
  • Confidentiality and Publication Ban:
    • Initial orders issued to protect documents. Court found insufficient evidence for their continuation, except for parts identifying the complainant?.
  • Conclusion: Motion for interlocutory injunction dismissed.
  • Costs Awarded: Respondent entitled to $30,000?.
Federal Court
T-853-23
Privacy law
$ 30,000
Respondent
21 April 2023