Giles v. Taylor
Francis Eric Boyd Giles
Law Firm / Organization
Self Represented
Diana Lynn Taylor
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

D. Young

Brian Earl Taylor
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

D. Young

Ultralight Sport Aviation LLC
Law Firm / Organization
Not Specified
Lawyer(s)

D. Young

  • Nature of the Case:
    • Giles, president of aircraft-related companies (World Aircraft Company and TG Airtech LLC), alleged that the defendants, residents of Michigan, owed him $783,000 USD for intellectual property (IP) rights to a light sport airplane and $31,200 USD for technical services.
    • Defendants contested the court’s jurisdiction and countered that Giles owed them money.
  • Key Points:

    • Jurisdiction:
      • Defendants challenged the court's jurisdiction, arguing the dispute should be heard in Michigan.
      • Court ruled it had jurisdiction since the plaintiff performed services in British Columbia and the parties allegedly agreed to resolve disputes under BC law.
    • Contractual Dispute:
      • Giles claimed the defendants agreed to purchase the airplane IP rights and pay for his services.
      • Defendants denied agreeing to pay for the IP rights and claimed Giles failed to deliver the airplane.
    • Loan Dispute:
      • Defendants alleged they lent Giles $200,000 USD to assist with the airplane’s production, which Giles denied.
    • Court Ruling:
      • The defendants’ challenge to the court’s jurisdiction was dismissed.
      • The plaintiff’s application for default judgment was also dismissed due to insufficient evidence.
      • Neither party was fully successful in terms of substantive claims.
    • Costs:
      • Defendants were ordered to pay costs related to the jurisdictional challenge and the plaintiff’s applications for default judgment. The exact monetary value was not specified.
Supreme Court of British Columbia
S210388
Intellectual property
Other